YOU SAID:
Have you seen the muffin man
INTO JAPANESE
あなたはマフィンの人を見ましたか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Did you see a muffin guy?
INTO JAPANESE
あなたはマフィンの人を見ましたか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Did you see a muffin guy?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.