YOU SAID:
I like you like butter on my bread
INTO JAPANESE
私のパンにバターが好きなのが好き
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I like butter to my bread
INTO JAPANESE
私はパンにバターが好きです
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I like butter to bread
INTO JAPANESE
私はパンにバターが好きです
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I like butter to bread
That didn't even make that much sense in English.