YOU SAID:

I went to a party and watched everyone like a creep

INTO JAPANESE

私はパーティーに行き、みんながクリープのように見ていました

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I went to the party and everyone was looking like a creep

INTO JAPANESE

私はパーティーに行って、誰もがクリープのように見えていた

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I went to the party and everyone was looking like a creep