YOU SAID:

If I gave her cotton candy, she would eat it.

INTO JAPANESE

私は彼女の綿菓子を与えた、彼女はそれを食べると思います。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I think I gave her candy, she eats it.

INTO JAPANESE

私は彼女のお菓子を与え、彼女はそれを食べると思います。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I think I gave her candy, she eats it.