YOU SAID:

if i were a goat i would be finger licken good

INTO JAPANESE

私はヤギだった場合私は指でいいね

BACK INTO ENGLISH

If I was a goat I'd like with a finger

INTO JAPANESE

私がヤギだったら指で欲しい

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I want a finger if I am a goat

INTO JAPANESE

私はヤギであれば私は指が欲しい

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I want a finger if I am a goat