YOU SAID:

My carrot fell of of a garage while i was eating it

INTO JAPANESE

食べているうちにニンジンがガレージから落ちた

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Carrots fell from the garage while eating

INTO JAPANESE

にんじんは食べながらガレージから落ちました

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Carrots fell out of the garage while eating

INTO JAPANESE

ニンジンは食べている間にガレージから落ちました

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Carrots fell out of the garage while eating