YOU SAID:

Ow! My eye! I'm not supposed to get pudding in it!

INTO JAPANESE

わぁ！私の目！プリンが入ってないはず！

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Wow! My eyes! There should be no pudding!

INTO JAPANESE

うわー！私の目！プリンがあってはいけません！

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Wow! My eyes! There should be no pudding!