YOU SAID:
Peanut butter tastes good on cats
INTO JAPANESE
ピーナッツバターは猫においしい
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Peanut butter is delicious for cats
INTO JAPANESE
ピーナッツバターは猫に美味しい
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Peanut butter is delicious for cats
That didn't even make that much sense in English.