YOU SAID:
she made a stinky, I liked it
INTO JAPANESE
彼女は臭いした、私はそれが好きだった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
She smelled, I liked it
INTO JAPANESE
彼女は匂いを嗅いだ、私はそれが好きだった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
She smelled, I liked it
That didn't even make that much sense in English.