YOU SAID:

What if dogs were not dogs but they were cats but also fish?

INTO JAPANESE

犬が犬ではなく猫でも魚でもあるとしたらどうでしょうか。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

What if the dog was not a dog but a cat or a fish?

INTO JAPANESE

犬が犬ではなく猫や魚だったら？

BACK INTO ENGLISH

If the dog is not a dog but a cat or fish?

INTO JAPANESE

犬が犬ではなく猫や魚であれば？

BACK INTO ENGLISH

If the dog is not a dog but a cat or fish?