YOU SAID:

I eat a petter in a petter

INTO JAPANESE

私はペッターでペッターを食べる

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I eat a petter with a petter

INTO JAPANESE

私はペッターとペッターを食べる

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I eat a petter and a petter

INTO JAPANESE

私はペッターとペッターを食べる

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I eat a petter and a petter