YOU SAID:
There once was a man who caught a large fish. The fish talked to him and fell back into the water. The man was so surprised he never fished again.
INTO JAPANESE
かつて大きな魚を捕まえた男がいました。魚は彼に話しかけ、水に落ちました。男は二度と釣りをしなかったことにとても驚いた。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Once there was a man who caught a big fish. The fish talked to him and fell into the water. The man was very surprised that he never fished again.
INTO JAPANESE
かつて大きな魚を捕まえた男がいました。魚は彼に話しかけ、水に落ちました。男は二度と釣りをしなかったことに非常に驚いた。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Once there was a man who caught a big fish. The fish talked to him and fell into the water. The man was very surprised that he never fished again.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.