YOU SAID:

why would you eat a cucumber when you could give one away instead

INTO JAPANESE

きゅうりをあげてもいいのに、なぜきゅうりを食べるのですか

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Why do you eat cucumbers when you can give them cucumbers

INTO JAPANESE

きゅうりを与えられるのに、なぜきゅうりを食べるのですか

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Why do you eat cucumbers when you can give them cucumbers