YOU SAID:
why would you say that my dude
INTO JAPANESE
なぜあなたは私の男だと言いますか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why are you saying that you are my man?
INTO JAPANESE
なぜあなたは私の男だと言っているのですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why are you saying that you are my man?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.