YOU SAID:

you can bring a horse to water, but you can't make it drink

INTO JAPANESE

馬を水に連れて行くことはできますが、飲むことはできません

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Horses can be taken to the water, but not drinkable

INTO JAPANESE

馬は水に連れて行くことができますが、飲めません

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Horses can be taken to the water but cannot drink

INTO JAPANESE

馬は水に連れて行くことができますが、飲むことはできません

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Horses can be taken to the water but cannot drink