YOU SAID:

i would stick my middle toe up at you

INTO JAPANESE

私はあなたに私の中指を突き刺します

BACK INTO ENGLISH

i stick my middle finger in you

INTO JAPANESE

私はあなたの中指を突き刺します

BACK INTO ENGLISH

i will stick your middle finger

INTO JAPANESE

私はあなたの中指を突き刺します

BACK INTO ENGLISH

i will stick your middle finger